Good sugar vs. dangerous sugar, what is the distinction?

Good sugar vs. bad sugar, what's the difference?

Angela Lang/CNET

Few meals have a worse popularity within the wellness and vitamin world than sugar. The US Workplace of Illness Prevention and the World Well being Group say you need to get not more than 10% of your each day energy from added sugar every day — and even higher is limiting added sugar to 25 grams (or six teaspoons) in whole. However, is it actually truthful to label all sugar as the identical? And what counts as “added sugar” precisely? 

Some folks will let you know sugar is sugar it doesn’t matter what, whereas others argue some types of sugar are higher and sure, even more healthy than others. While you have a look at the analysis, there may be no proof to obviously state that diets with naturally occurring sugar are dangerous in your well being. 

Under, Jayne Williams, a licensed dietary marketing consultant and medical vitamin graduate pupil weighs in to shed some mild on the several types of sugar and the way they have an effect on your well being.

Learn extra: Sugar vs. synthetic sweeteners — which is more healthy? It is difficult

The several types of sugars, defined

Added sugar is any kind of sugar that you simply (or a producer) add to meals — whether or not that’s coconut sugar, cane sugar, maple syrup, honey or agave nectar. However that is when the actual gray space of the sugar debate seems, as a result of every of those sugars are completely different by way of how they’re made or discovered.

On the subject of sugar in meals there are a number of essential elements to think about: If there may be added sugar and the sugar comes from a pure supply, or is present in a complete meals. For instance, fruit is a complete, pure meals and incorporates sugar in its pure type. It additionally incorporates quite a lot of different nutritional vitamins, minerals and vitamins. 

The World Well being Group notes of their tips that once they check with sugar consumption solutions, the ten% restrict would not check with sugar that is discovered naturally in meals like fruit or milk. So the very first thing to differentiate is added sugar versus the naturally occurring kind.

“I prefer to categorize sugar in three classes: Pure, modified pure sugar and faux sugar. Then we are able to begin to differentiate between what can have added advantages and what can simply downright trigger points in our physique,” Williams says.  

Pure sugars

Meals that naturally include sugar aren’t the identical as processed meals with added sugars. Meals that include pure sugar possible have much less sugar than a processed snack, and added advantages from nutritional vitamins, minerals or fiber, for instance. Added sugars reminiscent of excessive fructose corn syrup are sometimes extra processed types of sugar as effectively.


Fruit incorporates a type of sugar known as fructose.

Getty Pictures

All sugar impacts your physique by elevating your blood sugar and insulin hormones while you eat it. Nonetheless, it is possible that the meals you eat that naturally include sugar have far lower than processed meals and likewise include fiber, nutritional vitamins and minerals.

“Pure sugar, just like the sugar present in complete meals like fruits, is unquestionably a part of a nutritious diet for most individuals. Whereas fruits do include low ranges of fructose, which is a sugar, the general dietary worth of a bit of complete fruit with all of the nutritional vitamins, fiber and vitamins is effectively price together with in a nutritious diet,” Williams says. Pure-occurring fructose in fruits is certain to fiber, which helps decelerate how briskly your physique absorbs that sugar.

Fructose is to not be confused with excessive fructose corn syrup. “Fructose is far sweeter than glucose so it is most frequently used as a sweetener in processed meals. This sort of fructose is definitely manufactured and we all know it as excessive fructose corn syrup. This sort of chemical-made fructose is way from it is extraordinarily distant relative fructose by the point it is compounded right into a syrup,” Williams says.

Modified pure sugars


Honey, despite the fact that it is pure, remains to be a type of sugar. 

Getty Pictures

“Modified pure sugars are people who begin from a pure supply however want slight ‘fashionable intervention’ to make it to your desk. Coconut sugar, uncooked honey and natural pure maple syrup all have some extra minerals and nutritional vitamins, however are nonetheless sugar and might have an effect on your blood sugar ranges greater than natural-occurring sugars in complete meals,” Williams says.

Processed or ‘pretend’ sugars

Processed sugars are missing in vitamin or well being advantages since they’re processed and stripped of any nutritional vitamins and minerals. 

“Pretend sugars are the varieties of sugars which have been so modified in labs and include excessive ranges of fructose making it very troublesome in your liver to course of,” Williams says. “Desk sugar in any type (cane, white) falls into this class, in addition to agave nectar. Whereas it’s low-glycemic, it has excessive quantities of fructose making it extraordinarily troublesome in your liver to course of, particularly if you happen to embrace it in your each day food plan.”

The underside line

Sugar that’s present in complete, unprocessed meals is prone to produce other useful vitamins that assist steadiness out the adverse results it could actually have in your physique. Should you do add sugar, reminiscent of honey, to your meals, it is best to maintain it underneath 6 teaspoons per day in whole. 

Watch out with seemingly “wholesome” packaged or ready meals, snacks and drinks like smoothies. These also can have added sugar. And for optimum well being, avoid synthetic sweeteners and different extremely processed types of sugar like excessive fructose corn syrup. 

The knowledge contained on this article is for academic and informational functions solely and isn’t supposed as well being or medical recommendation. At all times seek the advice of a doctor or different certified well being supplier relating to any questions you could have a few medical situation or well being aims.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts